The Crossley ID Guide: Waterfowl was published
in the summer 2017. It is self-published so may not be widely available at
present. It is available on Amazon for $40.00.
As in the style of the previous four Crossley ID Guide books, it
is a photographic identification guide. This book covers the regular and vagrant
species of ducks, geese and swan occurring in Canada and the United
States. It goes into more depth per
species than the other Crossley ID Guides. The 512 high grade glossy pages create a flexibound
book with a substantial weight.
Nearly full page or double page spreads attempt
to show birds as they would appear in the field through the use of murals
comprised of photographs of individual or groups of waterfowl inserted on to a
real life background. The scenes are
alive with activity set in appropriate habitat and season for the corresponding
species and plumages. The plates are easy on the eye with the learning process
setting in almost subconsciously as one takes a walk through the scene. The
details and colours of the birds at various distances are believable and
accurate.
The common species are shown with an abundance
of images. For example the two species of goldeneyes get a combined total of 12
pages of plates. They show perfectly plumaged spring drakes, first-year males
and adult males in eclipse, females and even ducklings. There are some scenes
showing both Common and Barrow’s Goldeneye for comparison. Those long time aches and pains most of us Easterners
have had about the head shape and bill colour of any plumage of Common and
Barrow’s Goldeneye should receive relief and satisfaction with this book.
The 17 pages of scoter plates are an exposé of the
obscure female and non-breeding male plumages possible throughout the year while
at the same time doing justice to the striking breeding plumage drakes without over
shining the spot light. There are numerous images of eclipse male and female Greater
Scaup, Lesser Scaup, Ring-necked Duck, Tufted Duck, Redhead and Canvasback to
help solve the identification, including sexing and aging, of those challenging
brown aythyas. The eight pages of
plates devoted to the four North American subspecies of Common Eider, a subject
close to my heart, is the most extensive collection of photographs yet published
on the subject in any one place. Yet, I
found myself yearning for more examples of close up adult drakes showing the
full details of the bill and head. Those
who find joy in dissecting Canada Geese into subspecies will find something to
sink their teeth into. The inclusion of ducklings at several stages of
development available for most species is a nice plus for this book.
The plates while functional identification aids
are often beautiful. Many look good enough
to be enlarged and framed. The Steller’s Eiders coming into land on brassy
water with a background of fog shrouded mountains is a beauty. You can almost
hear the nasal calls and feel the splashing water in the double page spread of
displaying drake Common Goldeneyes.
There is a brief descriptive passage across the
bottom of each page of plates. However,
if you can tear yourself away from the pictures you will notice that the back
one third of the book is comprised of written species accounts. The three to four page per species accounts containing
a wealth of information are divided into sections with these interesting headings:
Other Common or Regional Names,
Measurements, First Impressions, ID: In Depth and Similar Species, Year in the
Life, Geographic Variation, Sounds, Diet and Feeding Behavior, Nesting, Hunting
and Population and Conservation. Crossley’s
easy going somewhat narrative-style rounds out the corners of hard fact and
scientific knowledge.
The common species are allotted two range maps,
one for the breeding range and another for the winter range. With such space you might expect some fine-tuned
accurate detailed mapping of waterfowl ranges in North America but – NOPE! In
fact there are astonishing mistakes. You can sort of excuse the lack of mapping
the tiny breeding range of Blue-winged Teal in southwest corner of Newfoundland
as it is rather insignificant on such a large scale map. We are used to that, but when Northern Shoveler
is shown as breeding throughout Labrador and Northern Pintail is not shown as
breeding at all in Labrador then you are left shaking your head. The wintering
range of the eastern Harlequin Duck is shown as Maine to Maryland. What about the hundreds wintering in New
Brunswick, Nova Scotia and Newfoundland!? There are several incidents of incorrect
mapping of the winter and breeding ranges of waterfowl in Newfoundland and
Labrador that would be obvious only to the birders from this province. You have to wonder where the creators of the
maps got their information. The baseline map does not even show the existence
of Cape Breton Island or the entire province of Prince Edward Island! Oh well - you would not a buy a book like
this for the range maps anyway.
Ignoring the range maps, I think this book is a
masterpiece. The treasure chest of images makes this book invaluable. But who
needs this book? Your average field guide to birds covers waterfowl adequately
for your basic identification needs. Experts on bird identification will
perhaps have the most to gain from this book.
Little things come to light like the dusky underwing coverts of a female
Red-breasted Merganser versus the whiter coverts of a female Common Merganser
and the solid dark under wings of a female Common Goldeneye which could all magically
come into play on a snapshot flyby of ducks on some cold misty January morning.
This book has all the particulars for those who want to know a little more.
The Crossley ID Guide: Waterfowl is a
visual encyclopedia of North American waterfowl. The voluminous text is thorough with easy to
extract information. It is a pillar of a
reference book that deserves a place in every birdwatcher’s library. This will
be my first go to book for waterfowl queries from now on.
The eider watching season is starting up in Newfoundland with a number of Kings already found among the first arriving borealis Common Eiders.